Kash Patel, who serves as FBI Director, faced sharp criticism after prematurely declaring that the suspected shooter was in custody. The claim was quickly retracted, sparking confusion during an already tense 33-hour manhunt. Yet, by Friday, the FBI successfully captured the real suspect, a 22-year-old man from Utah.
False Announcement Sparks Backlash
On Thursday, Patel announced that the man responsible for Kirk’s death had been arrested. Less than two hours later, he retracted the statement, admitting that the wrong person had been detained. This error marked the second time authorities had briefly arrested someone in connection with the case, only to release them after questioning.
The premature statement immediately drew criticism. Fox News host Laura Ingraham reacted by calling the revelation “unreal.” Conservative activist Chris Rufo accused Patel of poor leadership and argued that Republicans needed to reassess the FBI’s current management.
FBI Faces Intense Scrutiny
While Patel’s retraction overshadowed the early stages of the investigation, the FBI ultimately succeeded in capturing the real suspect. Still, many observers pointed to flaws in the bureau’s communication strategy. Critics said Patel and Deputy Director Dan Bongino appeared too focused on social media reactions instead of prioritizing clear and accurate updates.
A lawsuit filed days earlier added to these concerns. Former FBI officials claimed they were dismissed under pressure from Patel and Bongino, who allegedly made staffing decisions based on online commentary. The case highlighted how social media chatter increasingly influenced FBI operations.
Confusion on the Ground
At the same time Patel claimed the shooter had been caught, Utah law enforcement officials held a press conference stating that the gunman remained at large. The contradictory messages fueled widespread confusion. On social media, users questioned the FBI’s credibility and expressed frustration at the mixed signals.
The delayed Thursday news conference added to the unease. Patel appeared alongside other officials but did not speak. His silence raised doubts about whether the bureau was being transparent with the public.
Read: Father Recognizes Tyler Robinson, Ending 30-Hour Manhunt for Charlie Kirk’s Shooter
Criticism from Allies and Observers
Patel’s handling of the crisis drew criticism even from conservative allies. On his “Warroom” podcast, Steve Bannon questioned Patel’s decision to fly to Utah simply to thank law enforcement and media partners. Bannon wanted details about the suspect and potential accomplices instead.
A retired FBI agent with two decades of service described Patel’s actions as “reckless” and “too quick to the draw.” The agent noted that the FBI has historically tried to shape public perception, but under Patel, the effort seemed “like that on steroids.”
Arrest Brings Relief
Despite the early blunders, Patel returned Friday with confirmation that the actual shooter had been caught. He praised FBI agents, local police, the public, and media for their roles in the arrest. Patel emphasized that he had been directing operations from behind the scenes throughout the 33-hour manhunt.
Flowers and photos placed outside the U.S. Embassy in Pretoria showed the global impact of Kirk’s assassination. Mourning supporters viewed the arrest as a necessary step toward justice, even as questions lingered over the FBI’s missteps.
Political Repercussions
The Trump administration has so far stood behind Patel. Sources close to the White House said his error should be seen in the context of a “fog of war” scenario, where events evolved rapidly and emotions ran high. According to one insider, the focus should remain on the success of the operation rather than the slip in communication.
Still, Patel’s critics seized on the incident to question his leadership. Rufo declared that Patel “performed terribly,” while others suggested that Bongino’s new role as deputy director added further uncertainty to the bureau’s structure.
Spokeswoman Defends Patel
Patel’s spokeswoman, Erica Knight, issued a statement defending his actions. She said the director remained intentional at every step of the investigation. Knight dismissed the criticism as “ignorant” and stressed that Patel’s commitment to justice never wavered.
“What mattered most was delivering justice,” she wrote. “And justice has now been delivered.”
Calls for Accountability
Even as the arrest ended the manhunt, calls for accountability persisted. Critics argued that premature announcements undermined public trust during a national crisis. Patel’s reliance on social media, combined with structural tensions inside the FBI, left many wondering whether the agency could maintain focus in high-pressure cases.
The Kirk assassination, already a traumatic moment for political activists nationwide, has now become a test of federal leadership. With Patel at the center, the FBI faces a challenge not just of law enforcement, but of credibility.
Follow us on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook,, X and TikTok for latest updates
